Executor Dispute Solicitors

Executor disputes arise when the person appointed to administer a deceased person’s estate fails to perform their legal duties, falls out with co-executors, or comes into conflict with the beneficiaries.

These disputes can paralyse the administration, expose the executor to personal liability, and cost the estate substantial sums in unnecessary legal fees and lost asset value.

Awdry Law’s contentious probate solicitors acts for beneficiaries, co-executors, and executors themselves in will and estate disputes across England and Wales. 

To speak with our contentious probate solicitors with expertise in executor disputes, call our team today on 01225 417111 or complete our quick enquiry form.

What is a trustee / executor dispute?

An executor dispute is a disagreement about the conduct, decisions, or suitability of the person appointed under a Will to administer the estate.

Disputes between executors, beneficiaries and trustees can easily arise in the process of administering the estate of a loved one. It can be a burdensome process, and people are often surprised by the amount of work required and the time it takes.

The functions of a ‘personal representative’ include:

  • Arranging the funeral
  • Applying for a grant of probate if there was a will, or letters of administration if not
  • Collecting the assets of the estate
  • Identifying and paying the debts of the estate
  • Preparing estate accounts and settling any inheritance tax liability
  • Distributing the estate in accordance with the will or intestacy rules
  • Making investments if trusts are created by the will
  • Safeguarding and managing the assets of the estate whilst the administration process is completed

A will usually appoints two or more people to act as executors who need to work together. There is, therefore, plenty of scope for disagreement during the administration process, and disputes can often arise.

Our expert team is experienced in managing disputes between executors, trustees and beneficiaries and can advise on the legal options available.

Before seeking advice on your dispute, you should read our guide on executor rights and what they can and cannot do. You may find that a delay is perfectly reasonable under the law.

Common causes of disputes with trustees and executors

Most executor disputes are caused by one of the following issues:

  • Lengthy delay without explanation: Many lay executors underestimate the time and complexity involved in administering an estate. Where delay extends well beyond the executor’s year without good reason, beneficiaries are entitled to challenge it.
  • Failure to communicate with beneficiaries: Residuary beneficiaries are entitled to information about the estate. An executor who ignores letters, refuses to provide estate accounts or withholds asset valuations is open to formal challenge.
  • Disputes between siblings: Problems often arise when siblings inherit a deceased parents property and one party continues living their rent-free or refuses to sell the property, delaying beneficiaries receiving their inheritance.
  • Mismanagement of estate assets: Selling property at an undervalue, failing to insure assets, neglecting investments, allowing tenanted property to fall into disrepair, or failing to realise assets in a timely way can all cause measurable loss to the estate.
  • Conflict of interest: An executor must not place personal interest above duty. Selling estate property to themselves, a family member, or a connected party at an undervalue is one of the most common examples and is regularly the basis for removal applications.
  • Misappropriation of estate funds: Using estate money for personal purposes, taking unauthorised payments as “expenses,” or transferring estate assets without authority is the most serious form of executor misconduct. It can result in personal liability, removal, and in some cases criminal investigation.
  • Failure to follow the terms of the Will: Distributing to the wrong beneficiaries, in the wrong shares, or ignoring specific gifts can give rise to claims for recovery against both the executor and the recipients.
  • Breakdown between co-executors: Where two or more executors are appointed jointly, they must usually act unanimously. A deadlock between co-executors can stall the administration entirely and is a recognised ground for court intervention.
  • Allegations of negligence against professional executors: Solicitors, accountants, and trust corporations appointed as executors can face professional negligence claims where mistakes cause loss to the estate.

How can I hold an executor accountable?

The law provides a structured set of remedies for holding an executor to account. The right one depends on the nature of the dispute, the strength of the evidence, and the outcome you are seeking.

The main legal remedies for holding an executor accountable include the following:

  • Caveat at the Probate Registry: Where the validity of the Will itself is in doubt, a caveat can be lodged to prevent the grant of probate being issued while the position is investigated.
  • Request for estate accounts: A residuary beneficiary is entitled to estate accounts on request. A solicitor’s letter setting out the request and the legal basis often produces the information without further escalation.
  • Application for inventory and account: Where the executor refuses to provide accounts, an application can be made to the Probate Registry or the court under section 25 of the Administration of Estates Act 1925 for an order requiring the executor to provide a sworn inventory of the estate and an account of their administration.
  • Citation to take or refuse a grant: If an executor named in the Will is delaying applying for probate, a citation can compel them to take the grant within a set period or step aside in favour of someone else.
  • Application for directions: Executors and beneficiaries can apply to the court for directions on specific questions arising in the administration, such as the proper interpretation of a clause in the Will or whether a particular asset belongs to the estate.
  • Application to remove an executor: Where the executor is unfit, has acted in serious breach of duty, or is in irreconcilable deadlock with a co-executor, an application can be made under section 50 of the Administration of Justice Act 1985 to remove and replace them. Removal is treated by the court as a last resort and the evidence must show that the welfare of the estate requires it.
  • Claim for breach of fiduciary duty: Where the estate has suffered financial loss because of an executor’s conduct, a claim can be brought to recover that loss personally from the executor. These claims can include claims for an account of profits where the executor has benefited personally from a breach.

How to resolve trustees or executor disputes outside court

The courts expect parties to attempt resolution outside court before issuing proceedings. Cost orders are routinely made against parties who rush to litigation without exploring alternatives.

In most trustee and executor disputes, the right strategy is a structured escalation:

  • Direct correspondence setting out the concerns, the legal basis, and the remedy sought
  • Renunciation or power reserved where one executor agrees to step back voluntarily, provided they have not yet intermeddled in the estate
  • Mediation with an experienced contentious probate mediator, which resolves the majority of executor disputes that reach that stage
  • Negotiated settlement dealing with the substantive distribution, the executor’s costs, and any compensation to the estate
  • Arbitration in the small number of cases where the parties want a binding decision without going to court

Removing or substituting an executor

Most disputes between executors or trustees are resolved through negotiation and mediation between the parties. However, where that is not possible, the High Court has the power to order the removal and/or substitution of an executor under the Administration of Justice Act 1985.

The grounds for removing an executor are:

  1. Incapacity – because of some physical or mental disability which prevents the executor from performing their duties.
  2. Disqualification – because of a conviction of a crime resulting in imprisonment.
  3. Unsuitability – because of serious misconduct or a conflict of interest. This is the most common ground on which applications for removal are threatened and made.  However, the case law is clear that friction between executors and beneficiaries resulting in rude or uncooperative behaviour or delay is not enough.

The conduct must be serious, such as stealing from the estate or causing loss, for example, by making payments not authorised under the will, or breaching the executor’s legal duties.

Frequently asked questions about disputes with executors

Can an executor be taken to court?

Yes. An executor can be taken to court by any beneficiary, co-executor, or other person with sufficient interest in the estate.

The most common applications are for an inventory and account under section 25 of the Administration of Estates Act 1925, for removal of the executor under section 50 of the Administration of Justice Act 1985, and for breach of fiduciary duty where the estate has suffered loss.

Court proceedings should usually be a last resort after pre-action correspondence and alternative dispute resolution have been attempted.

What happens if there is a dispute between executors?

Co-executors must usually act unanimously, so a disagreement between them can bring the administration to a halt. The options include negotiation, mediation, an application to court for directions on a specific issue, or an application to remove one or more executors so the administration can proceed.

The right route depends on the nature of the disagreement, the value of the estate, and the relationship between the executors. We act for co-executors on both sides of these disputes.

Can an executor be held personally liable?

Yes. An executor can be held personally liable for loss caused to the estate by their breach of duty.

Personal liability commonly arises from underpayment of inheritance tax, distribution to the wrong beneficiaries, sale of estate assets at an undervalue, misappropriation of estate funds, or failure to settle the deceased’s debts before distribution.

Personal liability can extend to the full value of the loss and is not limited to the executor’s entitlement under the Will. Professional executors face additional exposure through professional negligence claims and regulatory investigation.

Can a co-executor live in the estate property rent-free?

A co-executor has no right to live in estate property rent-free. Occupying the property without the agreement of their fellow executors and the beneficiaries places personal interest above duty, and the estate is entitled to be compensated through an occupation rent charged against the occupying executor’s eventual share.

Can I remove a co-executor or beneficiary who won't leave the house?

A co-executor or beneficiary who is occupying estate property and who won’t leave the house can be removed, though occupation alone is rarely enough without a further failure alongside it, such as refusing to produce accounts, blocking a sale, or obstructing the administration generally.

The court treats removal as a last resort, and expects the evidence to show the estate’s welfare requires it, which occupation combined with obstruction usually does.

What if my co-executor refuses to cooperate at all?

A co-executor who refuses to cooperate at all creates a deadlock the estate cannot resolve on its own, since executors are expected to act together over the property and finances of the estate.

Correspondence setting out the concerns is the usual first step, followed by mediation, and, where the deadlock continues, an application to the court for directions or for the uncooperative executor’s removal.

Defending executors against unfounded claims

Not all complaints against an executor have merit. Beneficiaries sometimes confuse a slow administration with misconduct, misunderstand the executor’s legal obligations, or pursue an executor for tactical reasons connected with a wider family dispute.

We help executors defend against unfounded allegations by:

  • Providing a clear written record of the steps taken in the administration
  • Producing proper estate accounts that demonstrate proper conduct
  • Responding to information requests proportionately and on a legally sound basis
  • Defending applications for removal where the executor remains fit to act
  • Representing professional executors facing negligence allegations

Executors facing serious allegations should take legal advice early. The earlier the response is structured properly, the lower the risk of the dispute escalating into formal proceedings and a personal liability claim.

Case study

Our client was the sole beneficiary of the estate of her late father. She was a minor at the time of his death and was living with her mother who was estranged from her father. The main assets in the estate were 3 buy to let properties. Each was tenanted and mortgaged.

The will appointed a firm of solicitors as executors but administration of the estate was delayed because our client’s mother made an application for financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. During the period of the delay the solicitors were inactive and failed to manage the rental properties.

We successfully issued a claim against the solicitors for losses to the estate caused by:

  • Failure to secure tenants for the rental properties which remained empty for many months
  • Failure to recommend a sale of the properties. The property market was in decline in the area and with the loss of rental income and mortgage arrears the properties went from positive to negative equity.
  • Settling the claim by our client’s mother under the Inheritance Act without requiring our client to obtain independent representation and court approval (which is required for settlement of claims by or against minors).

Speak with our executor dispute solicitors today…

The contentious probate team at Awdry Law offers specialist trustee and executor disputes expertise, helping people across England and Wales. Clear cost information is presented at the outset of all instructions and we aim to manage costs effectively throughout your case.

To arrange an initial no obligation consultation with our contentious wills solicitors, call us on 01225 417111 or complete our quick enquiry form below and our team will get back to you promptly.

Quick enquiry.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

News

The five stages of separation or divorce

Rarely, is anyone prepared for the end of their relationship. This applies to both parties i.e for the person who initiates the separation, and the person who is being left.
Awdry Law - Legal Solicitors in Bath, Chippenham, Devizes, Marlborough, Royal Wootton Bassett and Swindon.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.