Break Clause Lessons from Sterling House v IBO [2026]

Break clause in commercial lease

A break clause gives a landlord, a tenant or both the right to end a commercial lease before its contractual end date. 

For tenants, it offers a way out if the business outgrows the premises, needs to cut costs or wants to move somewhere better suited. 

In this post, commercial property paralegal at Awdry Law, Natasha Salman, looks at a recent court ruling that serves up many key things to consider for both landlords and tenants when a tenant seeks to exercise a break clause.

The recent ruling in Sterling House Ltd v International Baccalaureate Organisation (UK) Ltd [2026] has provided guidance to both tenants and landlords when exercising a break clause in a commercial lease.

Background of the case: 

The tenant in the case had exercised their right to a break clause on 23rd February 2026, which was conditional on the payment of all insurance and rental debts. The lease provided that the rent was due in instalments, with insurance sums due on demand. 

In anticipation of the break, the tenant requested an invoice from the landlord’s managing agents to show all outstanding payments due for insurance and rent. 

The managing agents issued an invoice for rent due between 22 December 2025 to 23 February 2026, not accounting for the whole quarter. 

The tenant settled this amount on February 13th. Then, just days before the break date, the landlord issued an insurance sum demand. 

The landlord made a claim that the break clause was invalid, on the basis that the tenant had not satisfied the break conditions due to the outstanding rental sums.

The High court Judgment: 

The High court took the view that the managing agent had provided a clear representation of the sums that were due by the tenant in order to execute a valid break. 

The tenant sought the invoice to ensure compliance with the break clause and had reasonably relied on the representation made by the managing agent. The court decided therefore that the tenant could break the lease and in addition that no further sums were due. 

Moreover, by demanding the insurance sums a few days before the break clause, the landlord had not provided the tenant with a reasonable opportunity to make this payment before the break date which added further support to the Tenant’s position. 

Practical lessons to consider for landlords and tenants:

The judgment is important for both tenants and landlords and will be considered by tenants when looking to exercise break clauses. 

They are likely to seek confirmation prior to the relevant dates of all outstanding sums and then seek to rely on this judgment if they are not advised of all outstanding sums in good time. 

For landlords, and managing agents acting on their behalf, the accuracy of all statements and invoices are stressed, even more so where the tenant relies on them. Landlords are also reminded to be reasonable in the time that they give the tenant to make payment for outstanding sums prior to the break date coming into effect. 

Need help with a commercial lease break clause? How we can help…      

Awdry Law’s commercial property solicitors help landlords and tenants across Wiltshire and the South West of England with commercial lease break clauses, from checking the break conditions and confirming in writing the rent and insurance sums due, to preparing and reviewing break notices. 

As the Sterling House case shows, raising these points well before the break date gives time to resolve any discrepancy in the figures and reduces the risk of the break being challenged.

[team_member_info]

Quick enquiry.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

News

Making a Will? Appointing a professional executor can provide peace of mind at a very difficult time

If you are making a Will it is important to consider who you should appoint as an executor. There can be a lot of paperwork and legal or financial issues to deal with at a very difficult time.
Awdry Law - Legal Solicitors in Bath, Chippenham, Devizes, Marlborough, Royal Wootton Bassett and Swindon.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.